Guide

Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: Costs and Which Suits Your Home

A heat pump costs £7,000 to £14,000 to fit before grants and works differently from a boiler. Compare upfront cost, running costs, hot water and disruption.

Illustration of balance scales with an outdoor heat pump unit on one pan and a wall-hung boiler on the other, a flame symbol and a leaf symbol above them

A heat pump costs more to fit than a boiler and works in a different way, so the comparison isn't just about the price tag. This guide covers the things that actually decide it for most households: upfront cost, running cost, hot water, comfort and disruption. It assumes you're replacing a gas, oil or LPG boiler.

How they differ

A gas boiler burns fuel to make hot water at a high temperature. An air source heat pump uses electricity to move heat from the outside air into your heating system, at a lower temperature and for much longer periods. That's why radiators feel warm rather than hot, and why design matters so much.

Heat pump and gas boiler compared

Air source heat pumpGas boiler
Upfront costTypically £7,000–£14,000 before grantsUsually lower than a heat pump
Grant support£7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme in England and Wales, where eligibleNone
Heating styleLower water temperature, longer runningHigher temperature, shorter bursts
Hot waterNeeds a suitable cylinderCombi boilers heat on demand, so need no cylinder
UpkeepAnnual service often needed for warrantyAnnual service commonly advised

Upfront cost

The installation price depends on the house, as our installation cost guide explains. Where you qualify, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme takes £7,500 off. The sums are in what you pay after the grant. Check current amounts and eligibility for your nation on gov.uk before you decide.

Running cost

This is where it gets less clear-cut. A heat pump delivers several units of heat for each unit of electricity, but electricity usually costs more per unit than gas. Whether you save depends on your tariff, how well the system is designed and how well the house keeps its heat. Be wary of any single savings figure. A good installer will state their assumptions for tariff, efficiency and hot water use, as the surveys page asks.

Hot water, comfort and disruption

  • Hot water comes from a cylinder, so you need the space and a design that matches how many baths and showers your household runs.
  • Rooms are usually heated steadily rather than in bursts. Some people like the evenness, others miss the quick blast.
  • Installation typically takes two to five days, with the heating and hot water off at points. Agree the shutdown dates in advance.
  • Radiators may need to change, which means some decorating disruption.
Off the gas grid

If you run on oil, LPG or direct electric heating, the comparison can look very different, because the fuel you're replacing is likely to be more expensive per unit than mains gas. Ask installers to model your actual fuel.

How to decide

Start by checking whether your house is suitable. If it is, a heat loss survey gives you design figures and a predicted running cost. Then compare real quotes for installation and check what the grant would cover. If your boiler still has years left, there's no rush to switch.

How to compare a heat pump with your boiler

  1. Check suitability

    Review insulation, radiators, cylinder space and outdoor siting to see whether the house suits a heat pump.

  2. Collect your energy bills

    Gather a year of gas, oil or LPG and electricity bills so installers can model your real usage.

  3. Get a heat loss survey

    Ask for a room-by-room survey that states a predicted running cost and its assumptions.

  4. Check grant eligibility

    Confirm whether the Boiler Upgrade Scheme applies to your property and nation, and what the installer will deduct.

  5. Compare quotes like for like

    Ask each installer to separate the unit, cylinder, radiator changes, electrical work, commissioning and grant deduction.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas boiler?

It depends. A heat pump delivers more heat per unit of energy, but electricity costs more per unit than gas. Your tariff, system design and the house itself decide the outcome.

Do I lose my hot water supply on demand?

A heat pump heats a cylinder rather than water on demand, so hot water comes from stored supply. The cylinder should be sized to how much hot water your household uses.

Can I get a grant to replace a gas boiler with a heat pump?

In England and Wales the Boiler Upgrade Scheme offers £7,500 towards an eligible air-to-water heat pump, applied for by your installer. Scotland and Northern Ireland have different arrangements.

How long does it take to switch?

Installation typically takes two to five days on site. The survey, design and any grant paperwork happen beforehand, so allow several weeks overall.

Ready to talk to an air source heat pump installation specialist?

Get Free Quotes →